What Should Actually Go Into the Email

An email that doesn't get ignored

Picture the professor's inbox as a hallway of doors. Your subject line is the only thing visible from outside. If it looks like every other door, it doesn't get opened.

1. The subject line

Skip "PhD Application Inquiry" or "Prospective Student." These say nothing and blend into 40 identical ones. Be specific: Prospective PhD Student – Interest in [specific research area] – Fall 2027

If you're referencing a specific paper of theirs, even better: Question on your [Year] paper on [specific topic] – Prospective PhD applicant

Specific subject lines signal you're not spamming — you're addressing this person about this work.

2. The opening line

This is where 90% of emails lose the reader. Skip the throat-clearing ("I hope this email finds you well, my name is...") and get to the point in the first sentence.

Lead with the connection: "I came across your 2024 paper on [specific finding] and found your approach to [specific method] particularly interesting because it connects with a project I worked on involving [X]."

Notice: this opening already proves you read their work. That's worth more than three paragraphs of "I am passionate about research."

3. The middle — your fit, briefly

This is not the place for your entire CV in prose form. Two to three sentences, max:

• What you've done that's relevant (one specific project or result, not a list)

• Why it connects to their specific work, not research "in general"

• What you're hoping to explore or contribute

The keyword here is specific. "I am interested in machine learning" says nothing. "I'm interested in how your lab's work on graph neural networks could apply to the anomaly detection problem I worked on during my thesis" says everything.

4. The actual ask

Be direct about what you want. Vague emails get vague (or no) responses. Pick one clear ask:

• "Do you expect to have openings for PhD students starting Fall 2027?"

• "Would you be open to a short call to discuss your ongoing work in [X]?"

• "I noticed the application deadline is in December — should I mention your name specifically in my SOP, or is admission handled centrally by the committee?"

One question. Not five. A PI can answer one question in 30 seconds. Five questions turns your email into homework.

5. The close

Keep it short. Attach your CV (as a PDF, well-formatted, never a Google Drive link they have to click through). Mention your CV is attached, thank them for their time, and stop. No "looking forward to hearing from you soon" pressure — just a clean, confident close.

What not to write?

• Flattery without substance — "your esteemed research" and "your groundbreaking contributions" read as generic and slightly desperate.

• Your entire academic history — GPA, every course, every award. Save it for your CV.

• Apologizing for reaching out — "Sorry to bother you" undercuts you before you've even made your case.

• Copy-pasted paragraphs across multiple professors — even if you change the name, generic phrasing about "your lab's important work" is obvious the moment it's compared to an email from a colleague down the hall (yes, professors talk).

Example that can be used

Template A: Reaching out before applications open, with relevant experience

Subject: Prospective PhD Student with Interest in Reinforcement Learning for Robotics – Fall 2027

Dear Prof. [Last Name],

I recently read your paper "[Title]" and found your approach to sample-efficient policy learning particularly compelling, especially the way it addresses the sim-to-real gap. During my master's thesis, I worked on a related problem — improving transfer performance for robotic manipulation using domain randomization — and ran into several of the same challenges your paper discusses around reward shaping.

I'm applying for PhD positions starting Fall 2027 and your lab's direction aligns closely with what I want to pursue. I wanted to ask if you expect to be taking on new PhD students for that cycle.

I've attached my CV for reference. Thank you for your time, and I'd be glad to share more about my work if useful.

Best regards, [Your Name]

Template B: Limited research experience, strong coursework/projects instead

Subject: Prospective PhD Student: Question on Your Work in Computational Biology

Dear Prof. [Last Name],

Your recent work on [specific topic] caught my attention, particularly your method for [specific technique] — it's a much more elegant solution to the problem than the approach we used in a course project I completed on [related topic].

I don't yet have formal research publications, but I've spent the last year building strong technical foundations through [specific relevant project/coursework], and I'm looking to move into research through a PhD. Your lab's focus on [specific area] is exactly the direction I want to grow in.

Would you be open to a brief call to discuss whether my background might be a good fit for ongoing or upcoming work in your group?

My CV is attached. Thank you for considering this, and I understand if your schedule doesn't allow for it right now.

Best, [Your Name]

Template C: Following up after silence (2 weeks, one follow-up, no more)

Subject: Re: Prospective PhD Student: Interest in Reinforcement Learning for Robotics

Dear Prof. [Last Name],

I wanted to briefly follow up on my email from [date] regarding PhD opportunities in your lab. I understand you likely have a full inbox, so no worries if this isn't the right time — I just wanted to make sure it hadn't gotten lost.

If it's more useful, I'm happy to wait until the formal application period, or to address any specific questions in the meantime.

Thank you again for your time.

Best regards, [Your Name]

A quick rule on follow-ups: one is professional, two starts to feel like pressure. If there's no response after that, move on — it usually means "not now," not "never."

That's the whole game. Not more emails. Better ones.

For more personalized tips or templates contact our team.

www.applywithmentors.com

Also connect with us via comments/ questions via our linkedIn page! Also send us suggestions for what you would like to read.